Fresh, Handcrafted Pizza in North Manchester & Pierceton, Indiana

Welcome to Keyhole Pizzeria, your local destination for mouthwatering, freshly made pizzas in North Manchester and Pierceton, Indiana! As a proud member of the community, we take pride in serving up delicious, handcrafted pizzas made with the finest ingredients and a touch of hometown hospitality. Our menu is packed with classics you know and love, from savory pepperoni and cheesy margherita to specialty pies loaded with fresh veggies and bold flavors. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite with friends, bringing the family for dinner, or hosting a celebration, Keyhole Pizzeria is the place where good times and great food come together.

Our inviting atmosphere is perfect for gathering together, enjoying laughter, conversation, and, of course, an unbeatable pizza experience. We're passionate about quality, which means every pizza is made to order and packed with the freshest toppings. At Keyhole Pizzeria, value and selection go hand in hand—take advantage of our special offers and enjoy fantastic savings on your favorite flavors! We believe in serving with a smile, supporting our community, and making every visit memorable. Experience the taste that’s been crafted specially for Indiana, and find out why Keyhole Pizzeria is fast becoming a local favorite. We can’t wait to welcome you!